Sustainate

Train vs plane

Train vs plane: how much CO₂ does the train save in Europe?

The answer from our own route data, ten popular routes side by side, and why other calculators show different numbers.

Taking the train instead of flying cuts your CO₂ by a median of 89% on the 1,979 European routes we compare where the whole trip is by train. On those routes the flight emits about 9 times as much per person. Across all 4,740 routes on this site, including ferries and coaches, the median saving is 86%.

The short answer

  • Train only: a median of 89% less CO₂ than the flight, over 1,979 routes.
  • Any ground option (train, ferry, coach or a mix): a median of 86% less, over 4,740 routes.
  • On none of these routes does the ground option emit more than the flight.
  • Every figure is an estimate for one person travelling one way, from the same model the route pages and the trip planner use.

Ten popular routes compared

These are the most in-demand routes in our data where the whole trip is by train, with no city used twice. Each links to its route page with the legs, changes and a map.

Train vs flight, one person, one way
RouteTrain timeTrain CO₂Flight CO₂Flight door to doorSaving
London to Berlin9h 32m15 kg119 kg5h 46m87%
Istanbul to Sofia10h 00m12 kg65 kg5h 11m82%
Madrid to Paris9h 51m17 kg135 kg5h 55m87%
Rome to Budapest14h 40m15 kg103 kg5h 35m85%
Hamburg to Warsaw8h 09m11 kg96 kg5h 31m89%
Vienna to Munich4h 00m5 kg45 kg4h 59m89%
Barcelona to Milan11h 40m14 kg93 kg5h 29m85%
Stockholm to Copenhagen5h 00m9 kg67 kg5h 12m87%
Birmingham to Cologne5h 57m8 kg81 kg5h 21m90%
Prague to Krakow5h 43m8 kg50 kg5h 02m84%

Train time is the riding time of each leg plus 20 minutes for every change. The flight’s door-to-door time adds 2.5 hours at the airports and 1.5 hours getting to and from them to the time in the air, so the two columns can be compared. Long trips by train often take a day, and the planner shows night trains where they run.

Why our numbers differ from SNCF, Trainline and other calculators

You will find other figures for the same trip. They are not necessarily wrong; they answer slightly different questions.

  • The flight includes its warming effect at altitude. We use the UK government’s DESNZ factors with radiative forcing (0.12786 kg per passenger-kilometre for short-haul flights). Calculators that count only the CO₂ from burning fuel show a flight figure that is roughly half as high, and so a smaller saving.
  • The train uses the national electricity mix. We multiply 0.05 kWh per passenger-kilometre by the average grid intensity of the countries at both ends of each leg (from 0.03 to 0.65 kg CO₂ per kWh in our table). Rail operators usually publish figures from their own power supply and their own loads. SNCF’s figures, for example, rest on France’s mostly nuclear electricity, so a French high-speed trip can come out lower there than here.
  • Distances are straight lines between stops. Real track is longer, so our train figures lean slightly low. The flight factors already include an allowance for indirect routing.
  • We count the trip itself: no building of trains, planes, tracks or airports, and no getting to the station or airport.

CO₂ or CO₂e?

CO₂e (carbon dioxide equivalent) puts other greenhouse gases and warming effects on the same scale as CO₂. Our flight figures are CO₂e, because the DESNZ factors include radiative forcing: contrails and nitrogen oxides at altitude warm the climate on top of the CO₂ itself. Our train, ferry and coach figures are CO₂ from electricity and fuel. Route pages label both “kg CO₂” to keep them readable.

The size of the altitude effects is scientifically uncertain. Including them makes flights look worse than a CO₂-only count, which is why we say so and link the factors we use. Even on a CO₂-only count, the train comes out far ahead on almost every route here.

Where the “trees a year” line comes from

Route pages say how many trees it would take a full year to absorb the flight’s CO₂. We divide the flight’s figure by 22 kg, the European Commission’s average for what one mature tree absorbs in a year, and round to a whole tree. Young trees take up much less, so read it as a picture of scale, not as an offset.

Check a trip yourself